February 3, 2021
The High Court has allowed an appeal by the action group opposed to New Hope’s controversial Stage 3 expansion of New Acland Coal mine, sending the original application back to the Land Court for a new hearing.
The decision in favour of the Oakey Coal Action Alliance was handed down by Chief Justice Susan Kiefel and four fellow justices on Wednesday morning.
The Full Court decision set aside orders made by the Queensland Court of Appeal on November 1, 2019, and by the Queensland Supreme Court on May 28, 2018.
The judges ordered that New Acland’s applications be referred back to the Land Court of Queensland to be reconsidered, and that New Acland pay OCAA’s costs for the High Court appeal.
However, both parties have to bear their own costs for the earlier Supreme Court appeal and cross-appeal.
In December 2019, New Hope described OCAA’s High Court action as “stunt” and “nothing more than a mechanism to attempt to delay a final decision” on the Stage 3 Acland expansion.
“We have been seeking approval to expand New Acland Mine for more than 12 years,” New Hope Chief Operating Officer Andrew Boyd said at the time.
“Over the past two years we have fought and won a series of legal battles against a handful of objectors to the project.
“This latest stunt by OCAA has nothing to do with groundwater or any other environmental issue.
“It is clear that this action is nothing more than an attempt to delay final decisions on Stage 3.”
- Download: High Court judgments by Chief Justice Kiefel jointly with Justices Bell, Gageler and Keane; and Justice Edelman (310kb PDF)
* * *
Farmers from the Oakey Coal Action Alliance say they are relieved and excited after the High Court found in their favour.
“It is a relief OCAA has been saved from any action against it,” OCAA president Aileen Harrison said.
“We hope that we can win from here on in and get the mine stopped, so we can save our water and land, and leave it for future generations.”
OCAA secretary Paul King said the result was a win on all counts.
“It is a better outcome than we could have hoped for,” he said.
“We have won on all counts and New Hope has been ordered to pay costs to the High Court.
“The High Court’s decision is, in our view, vindication that the Darling Downs is for farming – not coal mining.”
- High Court To Hear Acland Appeal
- High Court Key To Acland
- Acland May Go To High Court
- ‘No Further Barriers’ To Mine Approval
- New Hope Blamed For Lost Jobs
- LNP To Fight For Acland Jobs
- Acland Sent Back To Land Court
- Axe Falls As Acland Deadline Passes
- Petition Backs Acland Expansion
- Acland Expansion Moves Closer
- MP Welcomes New Acland Orders
- Mine Sent Back To Land Court
- New Hope Launches Acland Review
- Acland Farmers Celebrate Small Win
- New Hope Seeks Review Of Acland Coal Mine Ruling
- MP Urges Premier To Ignore Acland Ruling
- Court Rules Against Acland Expansion
- Lock The Gate Says Mine Threatens Water Supplies
- Step Closer For Acland Mine
- Water Decision ‘To Cost 700 Jobs’
- Mayor Calls For Acland Expansion
- MP Rejects Mine ‘Hypocrisy’
- Court Bid To Stop Acland Expansion
- New Hope Coal ‘Paying Acland Royalties To Itself’
- 1300 Objectors To Mine Expansion
- Petition Supporting Mine Presented To Parliament
- Anti-Mine Group Praises Acland ‘Review’
- First Tick For New Acland Coal Mine
- Anti-Mining Group Releases Acland Report
- Have A Say On New Acland
- Terms Fixed For New Acland Mine
- Call For Comments On New Acland Expansion
- New Hope For Acland Miners